The SMRT will be issuing fines for people caught eating in the MRT trains. This followed the rise in the number caught eating in the train where it is prohibited and comes with a fine of S$500. Eating in the train is a minor issue, but the problem is a larger one.
If one looks around today, it is hardly surprising to see people breaking the rules. It is not difficult to see people blatantly throwing rubbish, jaw-walking, indiscreminate parking, and the latest "fad", that of eating in the trains. All may be minor offences. All should not have made it to national news. But the implications are important.
Firstly, why do people nowadays seemed to break rules? It is a quirkiness of the times? I remember many years ago when people would think twice before throwing that piece of rubbish; or trying looking for that pedestrian crossing before attempting to jay-walk. What has changed since? Now it seemed that breaking the rules is something to be proud of, no longer needed to be carried out away from prying eyes.
Secondly, minor offence they may be but underlying all this is the issue of discipline. If one can easily breaks such simple rules, what about more serious offences? The temptation to eat in the train is small, the rewards are small. If a person has no discipline to control himself over such small temptation and rewards, does he stand a chance to deal with bigger temptations? As the saying goes, "Everyone has a price". If such small rewards can make one break the law, then there is nothing to stop him from committing more serious offences, is there?
Thirdly, the next generation. If such minor offence is tolerated and accepted by the current generation, wouldn't the next generation be worse? Once upon a time, holding hands between teenagers was a taboo. Then it became accepted, and so teenagers goes a step further - hugging in public. This was eventually 'tolerated', and so there was kissing in public. All this changes takes place in within two generations. Previously, the kissing couple felt embarassed when caught, now the onlookers are the ones feeling embarrassed! Similarly, now innocuous rules are blatantly broken, what is there to stop further slides?
Fourthly, if everyone were to break the law, how will it affect the society? Already our society is so cosmopolitan with so many differentiation - heartlanders, foreign talents, white collar, etc - hard as it is to keep calm and harmony. However if everyone choose to break the rules, even those of the minimum commonly accepted social grace, wouldn't everyone's life be affected? Everyone will suffer, not just those who choose to infringe the law.
I think it is good that SMRT is doing something to stem such menace. However I do not think that issuing fine will solve the problem. It is always easy to say that education is important but alas despite the rise in our educational level, more and more such problems had surfaced.
The answer lies with the person himself - having the courage to choose to do right, having the courage to choose not to hurt the next person beside him and having the courage to say that he does not need any rules because whatever he do, he do it for himself.
How can we cultivate such a person, is, unfortunately the question.
Ref:
The Strait Times, 15 Aug 2007:
Why don't S'poreans take 'no eating' sign seriously? [Archives]
The Strait Times, 6 Jul 2009:
Drink-and-eat MRT offenders on the rise [Archives]
Thursday, July 16, 2009
It is not about eating in MRT trains but ....
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
Don't you think education is more important than keep coming up with new rules and new fines? What I mean by "education" is civic education, it has nothing to do with education "level".
I agree the answer lies with the person himself for his own action. One should not be inconsiderate.
I enjoy reading this entry and I have put a link from my entry regarding SMRT taking action too. Just to let you know. :)
Rssmatters, of course education is more important than new rules and fines. Civic education is but a subset of education. Civic education is sometimes just plain common sense. How many of us know fully well that we should not throw rubbish indiscrimately. and yet it is all too easy to see paper cups, tissue papers, etc thrown in lifts, etc. I am sure all of us had been taught not to do so by our parents, teachers, champaigns, etc. Many years ago, when people were not so literate, it excusable because maybe they do not understand the words "Please do not eat or drink", or maybe they do not comprehend what the signboard means, or maybe even do not understand the messages announced thru the PA system. But with more than 90% of our population having gone thru schools, it is hard to justify why there do not understand such simple instructions. And if you looked at the photos published, I am sure they will be offended if you say there are uneducated!
At the end of the day, it is not about (civic) education, but the attitude that counts. Like the saying goes, you can bring a horse to the river but you can't make it drink.
Post a Comment